Sound Advice
I’m currently reading through Stephanie Pearl-McPhee’s latest book — Knitting Rules. I sincerely enjoy receiving useful and practical information in a highly entertaining and well written manner and this book meets all the criteria.
After yesterday’s post, I delved into the chapter on yarn. It is appropriately named “Yarn and How Not to Feel Guilty About It.” She made some very good points on the merits of stash acquisition — some a little tongue and cheek and others that were more serious. Given my confession yesterday that I have a hard time committing to spending money on yarn and almost no stash to speak of, I figured that this would hold some valuable advice. Perhaps result in a more balanced approach that would allow me to purchase what I need and *gasp* occassionally what I want without the accompanying hesitation and panic and regret.
I was not disappointed.
She points out that if you were a carpenter no one would tell you that you had too much wood or, if you were a painter, too much paint and canvas. She also highlights the entertainment value and does a cost per hour comparison to some other popular forms of entertainment. Knitting, of course, is always the cheapest, because it takes the longest. Most importantly, she includes the caveat that as long as your ability to pay for the yarn is not exceeded by your actual purchases, you’re probably doing okay.
And lets face it, in this giant blogosphere we all call home, we have vastly different levels of what is a reasonable and responsible amount of money we can spend on yarn and its assorted trappings. There is no room for guilt in this equation.
One of the most important pieces of advice she gives in this chapter is “Buy the best you can afford. The stuff you make is your legacy, and your time is really worth it.” The best that can be afforded isn’t always going to be the most expensive and what it is you can afford will likely change from month to month and year to year as life fluctuates and alters its course. In the end, I have to agree with that kind of thinking.
Right now, as I have mentioned, I am knitting a shawl in some of the nicest yarn I have ever had the privilege to work with (earlier today in an e-mail I noted to someone that Alchemy Yarns should be given the knitting equivalent of an Oscar). I can’t remember the last time I worked on something that I was so completely, rapturously in love with. I find that I am unable to be away from it for longer than an hour at a time. I tried to bring it into my office just so I could be near it while I worked, but the temptation to gaze at it admiringly and not work was too strong. So I take frequent breaks and visit it in the living room. I don’t have to knit, just touch it, hold it up to the light. I’ve even named her — Ruby Joy (after a newly rediscovered friend’s spritely daughter and the sense of bliss I feel everytime I pick up this project).
To borrow a little math from our dear Harlot, the two skeins that Ruby Joy will be comprised of cost around forty dollars. The pattern estimates that this shawl will take twenty-four hours to knit. However, this is me we are talking about and with the Knittiot, lace always involves some amount of tinking, not to mention the time I spend just admiring it, so lets tack on another six hours just to be realistic. Forty dived by thirty gets us $1.33 per hour of entertainment. Not too shabby.
Before I close, let me also say that seeing the infamous Yarn Harlot in person was a treat. I have never felt so good about being told how utterly uncool I am. Really, I just felt a lot better about the whole situation.
April 12th, 2006 at 11:22 am
I love it! And at the rate I knit, it’s even cheaper per hour–why, I almost can’t afford NOT to knit!
Hooray for the Ruby Joys–both the sparkling child and the luscious shawl! My own cranberry stole (as yet unnamed) is nearing completion, finally–woo! Now, we just need to decide where we’re going to wear these stunning red wraps of ours. . .my coast, or yours?
April 12th, 2006 at 11:51 am
And Carol at Go Knit in Your Hat had some great advice about comparison shopping for yarn and how even with not much money, you can get nice natural fibre yarn. I think you need to match yarn to project as well so something like Briggs and Little (which is 100% wool, comes in good colours, and pretty cheap) is good yarn on a budget but you then need a project that won’t have it next to the skin. It just isn’t that soft. But it is great for an aran cardigan or sweater that will be worn over other things.
But that price per hour of entertainment calculation is valuable, too. Too many people compare the price of the yarn plus their time to the price they would pay to buy a sweater (or whatever) in a store. They don’t compare to a high-end designer sweater (which would probably be appropriate) but they also don’t consider that they don’t knit primarily for the product but for the enjoyment of knitting. Comparing to the price of a movie, is much more sensible.
April 13th, 2006 at 4:21 pm
oooooo Alchemy! I am envious! I have fondled but never bought! I couldn’t pick what I wanted! Show us some pictures! I want to see this distraction of yours!
April 14th, 2006 at 7:19 am
The price per hour is a convincing argument. Perri Klass said a similar thing in “Two Sweaters for My Father”.
April 18th, 2006 at 4:24 pm
Well, you have been touched by the Yarn Harlot linking to you. I love the name of your web blog!!!! Couldn’t help but come visit with a name like that!
You will probably get lots of hits now that you have been mentioned!
Congrats!
Cathy
April 18th, 2006 at 7:33 pm
I knit a Clapotis out of Alchemy silk for a friend who’s allergic to wool. It was worth every penny. It’s gorgeous - and I know she’ll wear it and treasure it forever.
I find that if I hate the yarn, I’ll end up hating the project. We deserve to knit with the best!
April 19th, 2006 at 9:08 am
I have several arguments to use on myself to justify buying good yarn, most of which are stated more eloquently by Stephanie in her books (I’ll see her this Friday, yea!). Right after this past Christmas I gave warning to everyone that their presents would be handmade, and the cost of the good yarn will be less than what I would spend otherwise. Can’t count the labor cost, because I knit too slowly, even using minimum wage. (My family wouldn’t believe that the knitted item is worth thousands of dollars, anyway.) So I get to do what I enjoy, and my family gets unique gifts.